Antigen Tests: Reliable For Travel Or Not?

As countries continue to reopen their borders to international travellers, most now require proof of vaccination, a recent negative COVID-19 test result, or both, for entry. The type of test required varies from country to country. For example, France requires a negative COVID-19 test (PCR or rapid antigen) taken no more than 48 hours before departure, while Greece requires a negative PCR test taken no more than 72 hours before arrival or a rapid antigen test taken no more than 24 hours before departure. The US requires a negative NAAT, PCR, or rapid antigen test taken within one day of departure. Antigen tests are widely available at drug stores and pharmacies and continue to be an effective way to determine infection.

Antigen tests are widely available at drug stores and pharmacies

The COVID-19 antigen tests are an effective way to determine whether you have been infected with the virus. They are also a quick and convenient option, with results available in about 15 minutes. The tests are usually priced at around $9.99, but some may find the cost prohibitive, especially if they have mild or no symptoms. However, it is recommended that high-risk groups, in particular, take the test.

When taking an antigen test, it is important to follow the instructions carefully and test at the right time. Testing around four days after potential exposure or the onset of symptoms is crucial to the test's success. If you experience symptoms but test negative, it is advisable to test again the following day to ensure accurate results.

While antigen tests are widely available, it is worth noting that their accuracy depends on the time since exposure and the level of virus in the test sample. They are considered to have "moderate to high" sensitivity during the peak viral load. As such, it is recommended to take multiple tests over several days to increase the chance of detecting asymptomatic infections.

Antigen tests are less accurate than molecular tests

Antigen tests are one type of rapid test that can be used to diagnose COVID-19. They are widely available at drug stores and pharmacies, and can provide results in as little as 15 minutes. However, they are not as accurate as other types of tests, such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR) lab tests, which are considered the gold standard for diagnosis by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

PCR tests detect the genetic material of the coronavirus, while antigen tests look for certain molecules found on the surface of the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Antigen tests are less sensitive than PCR tests because they do not amplify the thing they are looking for. This means that there needs to be a higher concentration of the virus in the sample for the test to be positive. As a result, antigen tests are more likely to produce false negatives, especially in the early stages of infection when there is less virus in the nose and throat, from which the samples are taken.

The accuracy of antigen tests also varies depending on the presence of symptoms. A March 2021 review of studies found that for people with symptoms of COVID-19, the tests correctly gave a positive result an average of 72% of the time, compared to 58.1% for people without symptoms. The accuracy of antigen tests also varies between brands, with SD Biosensor STANDARD Q scoring the highest in the review and correctly identifying a positive COVID-19 result in 88.1% of people.

Despite their lower accuracy, antigen tests offer several benefits over PCR tests. They are quicker, more portable and accessible, less expensive, and do not require a specialist or lab to interpret the results. For this reason, they are still useful for screening in crowded areas such as airports, arenas, and theme parks. However, if you have symptoms of COVID-19 and receive a negative result from a rapid antigen test, it is recommended that you confirm the result with a more accurate PCR test.

Antigen tests are cheaper than molecular tests

Antigen tests are generally much cheaper than molecular tests. Molecular tests, also known as PCR tests, are widely considered to be the gold standard of COVID-19 testing. They are more sensitive and specific than antigen tests, making them more accurate. However, this accuracy comes at a cost. Molecular tests typically take around 24 hours to produce results, and may take longer if samples are sent to an external laboratory.

On the other hand, antigen tests are much more affordable and accessible. The median price of an antigen test in an outpatient clinical setting was $42 in 2021, compared to $62 for a PCR test. At-home antigen test kits are even more affordable, with prices ranging from $8 to $13 per test. These tests can be purchased over the counter at pharmacies and drug stores, making them widely accessible.

The affordability and convenience of antigen tests make them a popular choice for travel. Many countries require a negative COVID-19 test for entry, and antigen tests provide a quick and easy way to meet this requirement. The tests are typically valid for travel if administered within a certain time frame before departure, such as 72 hours.

While molecular tests may be more accurate, antigen tests are still highly effective at detecting COVID-19 infections. They can identify individuals who are highly infectious, which is crucial for isolation and quarantine purposes. However, it is important to follow testing guidelines and use the tests correctly to ensure accurate results. Repeated testing, or serial testing, is often recommended to reduce the risk of missing an infection.

Antigen tests are quicker than molecular tests

Antigen tests are also more accessible and portable than molecular tests, and they are less expensive. They can be performed at home, long-term care facilities, or drive-through testing sites. The trade-off is that antigen tests are not as sensitive as molecular tests, so there is a higher chance of receiving a false negative result, especially if testing occurs a week or longer after symptoms start. False negatives are more likely when there is a lower amount of the virus in the sample.

Molecular tests, on the other hand, are more accurate because they detect the RNA or nucleic acid component of the virus. PCR tests, the most commonly used type of molecular test, can detect the virus even when there is a low level of viral RNA in the sample. However, results from molecular tests may take longer, around 24 hours or more, depending on whether samples need to be sent to an outside laboratory.

In summary, while molecular tests are more accurate, antigen tests offer the advantage of speed and convenience, making them a useful preliminary screening tool, especially in settings where rapid results are needed, such as airports, arenas, and theme parks.

Antigen tests are more suitable for asymptomatic people

Antigen tests are widely available at drug stores and pharmacies, and they are an effective way to determine whether you have been infected with the COVID-19 virus. Antigen tests are less sensitive than molecular or PCR tests, but they are capable of detecting the virus in patients who are still highly infectious, which is useful for isolation and quarantine purposes.

Antigen tests are particularly useful for asymptomatic screening. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing, which is considered the gold standard of COVID-19 lab tests, will identify many old persistent positives that are no longer infectious. This can result in the unnecessary isolation of individuals who pose no threat to public health. Antigen testing, on the other hand, will identify the vast majority of infectious positives, especially those with higher viral loads that are more likely to transmit to others. Antigen testing will, therefore, increase the certainty of benefit from isolation, reducing the risk of isolating those beyond their infectious period.

A 2021 study showed that rapid antigen tests were sensitive and specific enough to detect a person's viral load, whether they were symptomatic or not. Other studies have also shown that rapid antigen tests can provide more detail about viral load than has been widely promoted. This means that people can interpret their test results in two simple ways: the time taken for the test line to appear and the darkness of the test line after a certain amount of time. A darker test line or a faster test line indicates a higher viral load and a person's proximity to the peak of their infectiousness.

While molecular tests are more accurate, they may take longer to produce results, especially if samples are sent to an outside laboratory. Antigen tests, on the other hand, can provide results in as little as 15 minutes and do not need to be sent to a lab, making them more convenient and cost-effective.

Frequently asked questions