How Soft Springs Affect Full Travel

Springs are an essential component of any automobile, playing a significant role in both the vehicle's performance and the comfort of its passengers. The elasticity of springs allows them to absorb the impact of bumps and undulations on the road, converting this energy into potential energy that is then dissipated by the dampers. This prevents the car from bouncing uncontrollably and ensures a smoother ride. However, the stiffness of these springs is a topic of much debate, with some advocating for soft springs and others for stiff ones. This paragraph will explore the question: should springs be soft enough to allow all full travel?

Soft springs offer better ride quality but compromise handling

Soft springs offer a better ride quality but compromise handling. This is because soft springs have a lower spring rate, which means more force is acting on the tyre when there is a bump on the road. While this can absorb irregularities effectively, it also means that there is more body roll around corners. This is noticeable due to the higher spring travel.

Conversely, stiff springs have a higher spring rate, which means the car will handle better and have improved stability around corners. However, the trade-off is that stiff springs provide a poorer ride quality, with thuds coming into the cabin even on smaller, irregular patches of road.

The ideal spring setup depends on the purpose of the car. For example, a car designed for performance and thrilling driving experiences will have stiffer springs, whereas a car designed for daily commutes will have softer springs for maximum passenger comfort.

It's important to note that the spring setup is just one component of a car's suspension system, which also includes shock absorbers and anti-roll bars. These components work together to control the speed of the springs and improve the overall handling and ride quality of the vehicle.

Additionally, roads, driving conditions, driving styles, and curb weights can also impact the performance of the springs. As a result, finding the ideal spring setup for a car can be a complex task that requires careful consideration of various factors.

Stiff springs improve handling but offer a poor ride quality

Springs are an essential component of a vehicle's suspension system, absorbing shocks and vibrations while driving. While stiff springs offer improved handling and stability, they also result in a harsher ride quality. This trade-off between performance and comfort is a key consideration when choosing the appropriate spring stiffness for a vehicle.

Stiff springs provide better handling by reducing body roll when cornering or changing lanes. This helps keep the tires in better contact with the road, improving grip and cornering ability. Additionally, stiffer springs increase suspension stiffness, resulting in better control over vehicle movement during high-speed driving, hard braking, and acceleration.

However, one of the most notable drawbacks of stiff springs is the harsh ride quality they produce. The increased stiffness in the suspension system can cause discomfort to passengers, as they feel more bumps on rough roads compared to softer springs. This is because stiff springs have a higher spring rate, requiring more force to compress them by the same distance as softer springs.

The choice between stiff and soft springs depends on factors such as vehicle weight distribution and driving style. Heavier vehicles require stiffer springs to support their weight, while aggressive drivers may benefit from the increased stability and control offered by stiff springs. On the other hand, casual drivers may prefer softer spring rates for a more comfortable ride.

Furthermore, it is important to note that the ideal spring stiffness also depends on the type of road surface. Linear-rate springs, which have a constant rate regardless of compression, are ideal for smooth surfaces like well-prepared race tracks. In contrast, progressive-rate springs, which have varying rates depending on load, are better suited for street driving where rough surfaces are more common.

In conclusion, while stiff springs offer improved handling and stability, they come at the cost of a harsher ride quality. The choice between stiff and soft springs depends on a balance between performance and comfort, as well as considerations such as vehicle characteristics and road conditions.

Springs have a maximum safe travel limit beyond which they are damaged

The elastic limit of a spring refers to the maximum distance it can safely compress, extend, or torque without suffering damage. This limit is determined by the spring's design and thickness of the coils. For example, a compression spring with a free length of 1 inch may be physically compressible to a solid height of 0.25 inches, but its maximum safe travel may be 0.6 inches, meaning it can only be safely compressed to a loaded height of 0.4 inches.

If a spring is compressed beyond its elastic limit, it will "take a set," meaning its resilience and structure will be affected, and it will not be able to return to its original length. This is because the spring has been forced to withstand a load beyond its capacity, which has affected its physical structure.

It is important to know the elastic limits of the specific spring being used to avoid permanent damage. Spring manufacturers provide specifications, including maximum safe travel, which should be respected to ensure the spring functions correctly and has a long cyclic life.

Linear-rate springs are ideal for smooth surfaces like race tracks

Linear springs have a constant spring rate throughout their compression range. This means that the resistance felt through the steering wheel remains constant when taking corners, resulting in better maneuverability on road courses or tracks. The predictability and responsiveness of linear springs are particularly advantageous for drag racing and autocross, where a consistent spring rate is crucial for optimal performance.

The uniform nature of linear-rate springs also makes them well-suited for motorsports applications. Their predictable behaviour, due to the same spring rate throughout, ensures that the suspension system behaves as expected, even under high-performance conditions.

Additionally, linear springs are simpler in design compared to progressive springs, which have two subtypes: constantly increasing rate springs and dual-rate springs. Linear springs' simplicity makes them more reliable and easier to work with for racing setups.

While linear springs may provide a rougher ride due to their constant spring rate, this is a trade-off that racing enthusiasts are often willing to accept for the improved performance and predictability that linear springs offer on smooth surfaces like race tracks.

In summary, linear-rate springs are ideal for smooth surfaces as they provide consistent, predictable performance with a constant spring rate. Their simplicity, responsiveness, and ability to handle high-performance conditions make them the preferred choice for racing applications on smooth tracks.

Progressive-rate springs are ideal for streets with rough surfaces

The spring rate of a progressive spring varies with compression. The more the spring is compressed, the more weight is required to move it further. This dynamic rate makes progressive springs ideal for street use, where rough surfaces are common.

When driving on a rough surface, a progressive spring will initially offer a comfortable rate, but as the suspension compresses, it will provide a stiffer rate that improves cornering stability and feedback. This variable spring rate allows progressive springs to dampen bumps and provide a less jarring ride compared to linear springs.

In addition, progressive springs can be advantageous for daily drivers or vehicles that experience a mix of performance and casual driving conditions. They offer a smoother ride than linear springs while still stiffening up when necessary to enhance handling performance.

Furthermore, progressive springs are also suitable for vehicles that are frequently driven on streets with varying surface conditions. Their ability to adapt to different road surfaces makes them a versatile choice for drivers who encounter a range of driving scenarios.

While progressive springs offer benefits for street driving, it is important to note that they may not provide the same level of predictability as linear springs on a racetrack. The constantly changing spring rate of progressive springs can make performance prediction more challenging for racers.

Frequently asked questions